My ears have been pierced for 10 years, at 18 or 20g, I guess, and I decided to start stretching. I've been lurking this forum for a while, so I was surprised when the shop assistant said I could start with a 12g taper. I was skeptical, but I bought it anyway, and sure enough I couldn't get it more than halfway in without it hurting! (Even with lubricant, warm water, and massaging to get it ready

) As soon as the pain started I took the taper out right away - no blood or anything - and I've been doing sea salt soaks on it for the past 2 days.
My question is, how much should I downsize? Would it be worth my while to try a 14g taper, seeing as I got kind of far with the 12? Or should I start at 16g? Thanks for your help!